top of page

Unfair Competition by Insurance Companies?

Writer: Locksmith One
Locksmith One
7 days ago
5 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

📅 Date: 2025-10-10

🔐 Autor: Locksmith One


Insurance Provider or Service Contractor in Disguise?

In Puerto Rico and the United States, many insurance companies offer home, roadside, or vehicle assistance plans for as little as $6.95 per month. These plans may include emergency services such as locksmithing, plumbing, electrical repairs, glass replacement, pest control, and more.

Although these plans may initially seem convenient, concerns arise when insurance companies not only sell coverage but also perform technical services directly through their own employees.

In these situations, insurers may move beyond their traditional role as insurance providers and begin competing directly with locksmith businesses, repair shops, electrical contractors, and other specialized service companies.


The Underlying Conflict

An important question is whether insurance companies offering these services are properly registered with the Puerto Rico Department of Treasury (Departamento de Hacienda) for the technical activities they perform.

If an insurer provides locksmith, plumbing, electrical, refrigeration, towing, pest control, or glass repair services directly, several legal, ethical, and regulatory questions deserve examination:

  • Do these companies maintain valid Sales and Use Tax (IVU) registrations for their applicable business activities?

  • Do the technicians performing these services hold the professional licenses or credentials required by Puerto Rico law, where applicable?

  • Are these companies complying with the same inspection, insurance, certification, and tax obligations imposed on small businesses and independent technicians?

These questions are particularly important when the insurer operates as both the provider of coverage and the company performing the actual service.


This Is Not About Attacking Insurers: It Is About Fair and Transparent Rules

This article does not seek to attack legitimate insurance companies.

Instead, it raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest, regulatory compliance, and unfair competition when insurance providers also operate as direct technical service providers.

1. Market Distortion

Insurance companies may be able to offer assistance plans at extremely low monthly prices because their business models distribute costs across different insurance products.

Independent locksmiths and small technical service businesses operate under different financial structures and may find it difficult to compete with these subscription-based offerings.

However, a low monthly premium does not necessarily represent the full cost of providing an individual service.

2. Potentially Misleading Advertising

Concerns may arise when insurance companies advertise services through Google Ads or social media using search terms such as "24/7 locksmith" or "emergency assistance" without clearly identifying their role as insurance providers or assistance-plan administrators.

Consumers should be able to distinguish between a company selling assistance coverage and a business directly providing technical services.

3. Lack of Transparency in Professional Services

Customers should know who will arrive at their property and which company is responsible for the work.

If an insurer assigns an employee or subcontractor, the customer should receive clear information about the service provider's identity, qualifications, applicable credentials, and responsibility for damages or warranty claims.

Transparency is essential to maintaining consumer confidence and professional accountability.


Legal Questions: Can an Insurance Company Operate as a Locksmith?

In Puerto Rico, certain technical professions and regulated activities require specific licenses, permits, registrations, or professional qualifications.

The applicable requirements depend on the service being provided and the laws governing that particular activity.

When an insurance company also performs technical services, several considerations may apply:

  • Appropriate registration with the Puerto Rico Department of Treasury.

  • Business registration and authorization for applicable commercial activities.

  • Professional licenses or certifications where required by law.

  • Compliance with relevant consumer protection and tax obligations.

  • Liability insurance or bonding when required by law or contract.


The central question is whether an insurer that directly performs technical services meets the same applicable requirements as other businesses providing those services.

An insurance company's registration under multiple business activities does not, by itself, establish wrongdoing. Any potential violation must be evaluated according to the applicable laws and the company's actual operations.


Examples That Raise Concerns

1. Home Assistance Plans Without Clear Provider Identification

A consumer purchases a home assistance plan expecting service from a qualified professional.

When an emergency occurs, however, the assigned technician arrives without clear identification or information about the company responsible for the work.

This situation raises questions about transparency, professional qualifications, and customer protection.

2. Independent Locksmiths Competing With Insurance Assistance Programs

An independent locksmith in Puerto Rico purchases an assistance plan as a consumer.

Later, the locksmith discovers that the same insurer markets locksmith services within the same service area at prices supported by a subscription-based business model.

This situation raises questions about competition between independent businesses and large insurance organizations.

3. Paid Advertising Competing With Established Local Businesses

Advertisements using terms such as "24-Hour Home Assistance" may appear prominently in Google search results, competing with local locksmith companies that have established professional reputations over many years.

The concern is not the existence of paid advertising, but whether consumers can clearly identify the nature of the business offering the advertised service.


Proposed Solutions

At Locksmith24hours.com, now operating as Locksmith One, with over 40 years of locksmithing experience in Puerto Rico, we believe that transparency, regulatory compliance, and fair competition should guide the delivery of technical services.

1. Clear and Equitable Regulation

We encourage the appropriate government agencies, including the Puerto Rico Department of Treasury, DACO, and the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, to examine the regulatory requirements applicable to insurance companies that also provide technical services.

Relevant reviews may include:

  • Required professional licenses and qualifications.

  • Applicable business and tax registrations.

  • Compliance with consumer protection standards.

  • Accountability for services performed by employees and subcontractors.

2. Transparency in Advertising

Insurance companies and assistance-plan administrators should clearly communicate whether they directly provide technical services or coordinate services through independent contractors.

Advertisements should accurately represent the identity and role of the company offering the service.

Businesses should also comply with applicable licensing and registration requirements when advertising regulated technical services.

3. Consumer Choice

Consumers should receive clear information about their available service provider options.

Where permitted under the terms of their insurance policies or assistance agreements, customers should understand whether they can select their preferred qualified technician.

Any restrictions involving preferred providers, coverage limits, or reimbursement procedures should be explained before the consumer purchases the plan.

4. Protection of Fair Competition

Fair competition benefits consumers, independent professionals, and established businesses.

Regulatory oversight should help ensure that companies of all sizes operate under the applicable requirements without creating unjustified advantages or barriers to competition.

Protecting local technical businesses also contributes to employment, professional development, and Puerto Rico's economy.


Conclusion

Selling insurance coverage and directly performing technical services are two different business activities.

When an insurance company also operates as a locksmith service provider, plumbing contractor, electrical service company, or another technical business, it should comply with all legal requirements applicable to those activities.

The fundamental issue is not whether insurance companies should be prohibited from offering assistance services.

Rather, it is whether all providers operate under clear rules, maintain appropriate qualifications, and provide consumers with accurate information about the services they receive.


What is at stake is fair competition, regulatory transparency, professional accountability, and the consumer's right to safe and reliable services.


Have You Encountered Similar Practices? Learn About Your Consumer Rights

Consumers and business owners who have concerns about insurance assistance plans, service provider identification, or professional qualifications can contact the appropriate regulatory agencies in Puerto Rico.


Contact Locksmith One

📍 Address: 523 F.D. Roosevelt Avenue, San Juan, PR 00918

📞 Phone: (787) 664-5557

Comments


bottom of page